Deprescribing in Psychiatry

February 19, 2024

Dr. Richard Heckman will share his personal journey and experiences in the field of psychiatry, leading up to his unique approach to deprescribing. Gain valuable insights into the mind, exploring the realms of cognition, emotions, will, self-confidence, spirit, and conscience. Discover the importance of understanding different worldviews in mental health practices and learn what to look for in a mental health professional.

Read about this class:

Dr. Richard Heckman offers a reflective exploration into the concept of deep prescribing—the thoughtful reduction or adjustment of psychiatric medications. In his lecture, Dr. Heckman shares not just his expertise but also his journey through psychiatry, shaped by decades of clinical experience and evolving medical practices.

Understanding Psychiatry and Its Foundations

To lay the groundwork, Dr. Heckman highlights the essential distinction between psychiatry and psychology:

  • Psychiatrists are medical doctors specializing in diagnosing and treating mental illnesses, with the authority to prescribe medications.
  • Psychologists primarily focus on psychotherapy, counseling, and diagnostic testing but typically do not prescribe medication.

A psychiatrist’s role extends beyond prescribing—it involves understanding a patient’s worldview, which deeply affects how individuals process their experiences. Dr. Heckman underscores the importance of a practitioner’s respect for a patient’s beliefs, values, and life purpose.

The Core Elements of the Mind

Dr. Heckman outlines five fundamental aspects of the mind that must be considered in psychiatric care:

  1. Cognition: Logical thinking, problem-solving, and planning.
  2. Emotions: Spontaneous feelings like anger or joy that arise without deliberate thought.
  3. Will and Self-Confidence: The ability to make and stick with decisions, especially under emotional pressure.
  4. Spirit: The capacity for spiritual connection and reflection, often neglected in modern psychiatry.
  5. Conscience: An internal guide informed by objective moral standards, shaping one’s sense of right and wrong.

He emphasizes that modern psychiatry often omits spirituality and conscience, creating a gap in comprehensive mental health treatment.

The Shift in Psychiatric Practice: From Depth to Quick Fixes

Dr. Heckman reflects on how psychiatric training has evolved over time:

  • In the earlier years of his career, medication was used sparingly, with a greater emphasis on long-term, insight-oriented psychotherapy.
  • The shift toward managed care in the 1980s and 1990s prioritized quick, cost-effective treatments, focusing on prescribing medication over deep psychological exploration.
  • This change, driven largely by economic pressures, resulted in a loss of patient-centered care, where therapy became rushed and focused primarily on symptom reduction rather than root causes.

He illustrates this shift using the landmark Dr. Oshiroff lawsuit against Chestnut Lodge, which reshaped psychiatric practices to favor medication over long-term psychotherapy.

The Art of Deep Prescribing: A Thoughtful Approach

Dr. Heckman outlines key reasons for adjusting or reducing medications:

  1. Unnecessary Prescriptions: Medications prescribed for conditions that could be treated with therapy or lifestyle changes.
  2. Ineffectiveness: Medications that are not delivering the intended results.
  3. Phantom Medications: Drugs that patients are prescribed but do not actually take.
  4. Adverse Side Effects: Issues such as weight gain, fatigue, sexual dysfunction, or brain fog that diminish quality of life.

The goal of deep prescribing is not simply to remove medications but to ensure each prescription is necessary, effective, and supports the patient’s overall well-being.

Alternative Interventions: Beyond Medication

Dr. Heckman strongly advocates for non-medication-based interventions, including:

  • Exercise: Regular physical activity can be as effective as antidepressants for mild to moderate depression.
  • Social Engagement: Encouraging patients to build meaningful social connections to combat isolation.
  • Spiritual Exploration: Addressing existential questions and personal faith to help individuals find deeper meaning and worth.
  • Psychotherapy Techniques:
    • Insight-oriented therapy: Helps patients recognize unconscious patterns influencing their behavior.
    • EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing): A powerful tool for addressing trauma and PTSD.

Challenges in Modern Psychiatry

Dr. Heckman highlights systemic challenges that hinder personalized care:

  • Managed Care Pressures: Time constraints often force psychiatrists to focus on quick medication solutions rather than long-term healing.
  • Electronic Medical Records (EMRs): Though designed for efficiency, EMRs can compromise patient confidentiality and shift the focus from patient interaction to administrative box-checking.
  • Rising Mental Health Concerns: There has been an alarming increase in depression, anxiety, suicide rates among teens, and psychosis—challenges that quick medication fixes often fail to address fully.

The Importance of Personalized, Patient-Centered Care

At the heart of Dr. Heckman’s philosophy is clear, respectful communication. In the context of deep prescribing, this means:

  • Carefully prioritizing medication reduction based on symptom severity and side effects.
  • Collaborating with patients to understand their values and treatment goals.
  • Exploring holistic approaches, integrating psychological, spiritual, and physical well-being into treatment.

Conclusion: Restoring Depth to Psychiatric Care

Dr. Heckman’s lecture serves as both a reminder and a call to action: psychiatry should not be reduced to mere symptom management through medication. True healing requires time, empathy, respect for the patient’s worldview, and a comprehensive understanding of the human mind.

Through thoughtful deep prescribing and holistic care, psychiatry can return to its roots—helping individuals not just survive but truly thrive.

Read More